February 12, 2026 • training philosophy
People ask me all the time: “What's your dog training method?” And I get it—it's a fair question. The dog training world can feel like it's split into two warring camps, and most owners just want to know which side I'm on.
On one end, you've got the “purely positive” philosophy. The idea is that training should only be fun for the dog—no corrections, nothing unpleasant, ever. You ignore unwanted behavior and reward the behavior you want. The toolkit includes treat pouches, clickers, head halters, and a great deal of patience.
On the other end, you've got what people call “old school” or “yank and crank” training—heavy on corrections, aversive tools, and making the dog uncomfortable until he complies. These methods are often criticized as harsh or even abusive, and in many cases, that criticism is justified.
So which approach is right? The honest answer is that the best dog training method borrows from both—and the best way to understand why is to look at how dogs actually learn to be dogs.
How Dogs Learn Naturally: Nature's Own Training Program
When puppies are born, they're blind and deaf. Their entire world is touch and smell. As they start to move around, their mother is always watching. If a puppy accidentally wanders outside the safe zone, she calmly picks him up and brings him back. No drama, no stress—just quiet, confident action.
As the puppies grow and begin testing those boundaries more deliberately, the mother's response becomes firmer. She may grab a puppy and give a little shake to make it absolutely clear that wandering into danger is not going to be tolerated. To our eyes, this might look rough. But consider what she's protecting her puppies from—predators like hawks, coyotes, and fisher cats that would happily make a meal of a wandering pup. In a life-or-death situation, there's simply no time to “ignore” dangerous behavior until the puppy (hopefully) figures it out on his own.
Here's what's remarkable: those firm, clear corrections almost never need to be repeated. The puppy gets the message the first or second time, and the lesson sticks. That's the power of communicating in a language the dog is wired to understand.
Pack Leadership and Why It Matters for Dog Training
As puppies mature and begin traveling with the pack, the dynamics of leadership become even clearer. The pack leader walks out front and makes every significant decision—what to pursue, when to move, when to rest, and what to engage with. If a subordinate dog steps out of line, the leader issues a swift, convincing correction. It's not about anger or cruelty—it's about maintaining order, because the survival of the entire pack depends on it.
A pack that can't hold together can't hunt, can't defend itself, and can't thrive. The leader has earned that role through experience, composure, and the willingness to enforce boundaries—and the other dogs respect that because it keeps them safe.
This isn't just interesting trivia about wolves and wild dogs. It's directly relevant to how your dog at home is wired to learn and to relate to you as his leader. Training a dog in the way he's genetically programmed to understand is simply the most effective approach there is.
The Value of Positive Reinforcement in Dog Training
Now, does this mean purely positive training has no merit? Not at all—it absolutely does. But like anything, it needs balance and common sense. Here's how a purely positive approach might work in practice. You call your dog and then stand there, waiting for him to figure out what you want. He runs over—click, treat. He jumps on you—ignored. He scratches at you with his paw—ignored. He wanders away—ignored. Eventually, he sits and looks up at you—click, treat! The dog is learning through experimentation, and it's genuinely fun to watch. There's no discomfort, no stress, and the dog is figuring out that good things happen when he makes good choices.
That's wonderful—as far as it goes. The problem is that this is often where the training stops.
Where Purely Positive Dog Training Falls Short
Your dog has learned that sitting and looking up at you produces a treat when he hears a click. Great. But what happens when a squirrel darts across a busy street and your dog decides that squirrel is far more interesting than anything in your treat pouch? Can you really afford to stand there, ignore the dangerous behavior, and wait for your dog to make the right choice on his own?
That defies common sense—and it's where the purely positive approach can become genuinely dangerous.
Think back to the pack model. Imagine one of the subordinate dogs suddenly decides to chase a passing car. If he gets hit, he dies. The pack fractures, a violent struggle for rank sometimes follows, and the entire group is weakened. Would the pack leader tolerate this? Of course not. The correction would begin at the very first signal of insubordination—a look, a growl, or something more forceful if needed. It would be clear, immediate, and convincing. And it would rarely need to happen more than once.
The Balanced Approach: Common-Sense Dog Training That Works
So where does all of this leave us? With a common-sense approach that takes the best of both worlds.
As humans, we have tremendous advantages over a canine pack leader. We can reason, plan, and problem-solve. We can deliver rewards that are immediate, clear, and delicious. We can learn to read our dogs' body language and communicate in ways they're hardwired to understand. We can do all of this without yelling, hitting, or physically fighting our dogs.
The key is being calm, assertive, and unwilling to take “no” for an answer. That's it. That's the foundation.
Teach your dog what you expect. Reward him generously and genuinely when he gets it right—so generously that he looks forward to doing what you ask. But when he knows what's expected and deliberately chooses to do the wrong thing, you must correct him clearly and convincingly enough that he doesn't want to make that choice again. Not harshly. Not with anger. With calm, confident leadership.
What Balanced Dog Training Looks Like in Real Life
When your dog sees you as the leader—truly sees you that way, deep down—something remarkable happens. Lots of unwanted behaviors don't just get managed. They start to disappear on their own.
Imagine walking your dog and not worrying for a second about him lunging at another dog. Imagine an untrained dog pulling and straining toward you on the sidewalk while his owner struggles to hold on—and your dog calmly standing behind you, completely relaxed, waiting for you to decide whether this situation is worth engaging with. That's not a fantasy. That's what real leadership produces.
If you're caught in the debate between purely positive and old school, I'd encourage you to step back from both extremes. The answer isn't about choosing a team. It's about understanding your dog's nature, communicating in a language he was born to understand, and becoming the kind of leader he's been waiting for.
It Starts with Leadership
Training your dog becomes remarkably straightforward once you're established in his mind as the leader. Reward generously. Correct honestly. Be the calm, confident presence your dog needs—and watch as the relationship you've always wanted begins to take shape.
Who you are to your dog is EVERYTHING
Shawn Hines
Dog Trainer, Best Buddy Dog Training
Comments
You must be logged in to leave a comment.
Log In Register